Issue 2 | Why?

Download the second issue of The Phoenix here!

---

March 2025

Editorial | Second issue of the Phoenix

This is the second issue of The Phoenix. The first issue focused on Remembrance, timed to coincide with 17 December, Remembrance Day. The response we received was very encouraging, and now, we are proud to present the second issue of our publication.

This time, we have chosen the topic of ‘Why?’ – a question that can be both practical and rhetorical, addressing both small and fundamental issues.

Since we began working on this issue, however, the ground beneath us has been shifting considerably. The dissolution of USAID and the disappearance of a large portion of funding has a significant impact on many people – humanitarians delivering services, and especially those who depend on aid and support. Many must be asking: WHY? This is an assault on our sector, and we must question whether we can remain ‘non-political’, and whether neutrality and impartiality are still options we can afford to entertain.

Perhaps somewhat controversially, we have also included a contribution by ChatGPT in this issue.

The next issue will focus on Diversity and Inclusion – we invite you to share your experiences in this regard. While there will be a focus on female leadership, the topic is broad, and we would love to include contributions from male perspectives as well!

Please note that translations of most articles will be available on the website.

Christoph Hensch

---

Why?

By Sébastien Couturier

Why leave? Why stay? Why so much injustice, so much violence between colleagues, so much indifference? Why is my employer so unkind? Why have I become a stranger to everything, neither from here nor from there? Why so many unanswered questions? Why not kill myself?

I’m still looking for answers. But do they even exist? Or is the act of asking them what matters? This obsessive search for impossible answers began in 2001, with a decomposing body I had to collect. A gaping hole in his back. A wound so large it defied imagination. What could have caused an injury like that? A hole the size of a fist, tearing through his flesh. I searched. I found. And that answer confirmed my belief that everything could be explained. Even the most inexcusable horror.

Why did these “things” — because I can no longer call them men — do that to those women and children? That impossible answer opened another one. And me — could I be capable of doing the same?

What a terrible question. You have to have lived and worked somewhere where nothing exists anymore, in the middle of that anarchy idealized by certain ignorant people who dream of a world without faith or law.

In those places of war and conflict, forgotten by journalists, there is no justice, no police, no social pressure, no judgment. The raw circumstances of war make almost anything possible.

It is in that kind of context that we must all make a choice we will carry for the rest of our lives. There, everything becomes possible. I could give in to my basest instincts. For a few coins, without risk. The temptation is there. No more mask. No more rules. I reveal myself to myself, as I choose to be. No one is forcing me. It is my choice, for better or for worse.

What do I see in the mirror afterward, once the intoxication of transgression has passed? A bastard, or a man proud of having resisted temptation? Being alone with oneself can be terrifying. It is impossible to deceive yourself.

I believe we all have a conscience we must live with. My employer, comfortably seated in an office thousands of kilometers from the field, judged me guilty. Guilty of not having died trying to save those children at that checkpoint.

I should have died a hero and sacrificed myself for that impossible mission. Because how do you save anyone when you yourself are restrained and held at gunpoint? That is my fault.

The guilt instilled by the words of people I trusted ate away at me, destroyed me from within, little by little — and above all, pushed me to want to make up for it. Yet another why.

I have never needed codes of conduct to behave well when no one is watching. Just as I have never needed objectives to do my job well. To me, all those codes and charters are merely proof that those who write them have lost sight of what matters.

When money, title, and power are gone — what remains? Human connection, solidarity, empathy, and camaraderie. The bonds we weave with one another. Only those who have lived it know.

The field has taught me that even in the deepest hell on earth, there are beautiful souls. You have to dare to remain humble in the face of life’s trials. Dare to listen to your heart too. Act with kindness toward one another. Dare to ask for help without fear. That is the recipe for surviving “why.”

“Alone, we’re doomed — together, we survive.” No superheroes, just humanitarians. That is what I have taken away from all my missions.

I also have to learn to accept that some questions remain unanswered. But I haven’t managed that yet. Why?

Courage to all.

---

The most important question

By Christoph Hensch

As a parent, one of the most annoying questions we are asked by our children is: Why? While sometimes challenging to answer, it is one of the most important questions to ask, ever.

Especially as humanitarians, we are often confronted with the same question: Why? Before embarking on a humanitarian career, we have family and friends asking, “Why do you need to go?” “Why do you go to such dangerous places?” “Why do you engage in this kind of work when it’s not even well paid?” and so on.

Sooner or later, in response to doubts and other challenges, we are prompted to direct the “why” question at ourselves. “Given all the adversity, why do I insist on doing humanitarian work?” “Why, despite my efforts, does nothing ever change?” “Why, despite my best efforts, am I treated so badly by my employer?” or “Why is my work never acknowledged or recognized?” … and so on.

What is it that we are asking for when we ask Why? The dictionary defines this question as asking for the cause, reason, or purpose of something. “Why” invites both practical and rhetorical questions. It invites us to contemplate. “Why” questions can be small (“Why should I use this tool and not another?”) or large (“Why was USAID dismantled and all related funding cut overnight?” or “Why is humanitarian aid important?”).

With “why,” we can also question the basic reality of life: Why is this happening? Why are we alive? Why am I the way I am?

MY OWN WHY

Some people may go through a structured process to arrive at their personal “why.” Others might have sudden, violent, or otherwise traumatic experiences that lead them to their insight. For me, it was a slow, long, and tedious process, taking many years.

It was a process of turning upside down the worldview I learned from family, school, and other outside authorities. I had to learn to allow myself to listen to my deep inner Self and develop my own unique ways of deciding what is real, true, and important in my life and in the world.

As I live Life, every experience — especially the difficult, challenging, and adverse ones — adds depth and complexity to my “why.” My journey took me from working with money to working with people. I learned that we live in a global world, where not only the state of the environment in faraway lands matters, but also the collective well-being of everyone, living anywhere. While the state of our physical world is essential, consideration of what could be called the “Otherworld” is equally indispensable.

Then, one day, someone challenged me to write a personal mission statement. That was the opportunity to craft my “why” into a concise, to-the-point vision and purpose statement — one that I can use to measure my actions, the projects I get involved with, and the jobs I will seek and accept. Today I write it on top of my CV, and I published it on my LinkedIn profile:

My vision is of a world where all people (beings) belong, celebrate their diversity, live a culture of care and continually improve their physical and social environments.

What is your purpose and what kind of vision do you have for your life? What is your big and personal ‘why’?

---

Why Be a Humanitarian?

By Asma Rassouad

For many of us, the choice to work in humanitarian aid was born from a desire to contribute to a more just world — a world where everyone would have the same chances and opportunities in terms of quality of life, access to education, and access to healthcare. But we very quickly come face to face with reality: intensifying conflicts, crises that drag on, and above all, a general indifference. That same indifference which allows people to consider civilians as acceptable collateral damage in war, or to simply conclude that the world is the way it is and there is nothing we can do about it.

Add to that the challenges in the field, the bureaucracy, and the mental and emotional fatigue that can call our commitment into question. And yet, it is often in those moments of doubt that we rediscover our reason for being: an encounter with a resilient community, a child finding their way back to school, or simply the conviction that every small act matters.

About the author:
Asma Rassouad is a humanitarian specialist in development aid, based in France. She advocates for the involvement of local populations and the development of empowerment-based solutions

---

Finding Your Personal Why: The Compass That Guides Us When Everything Falls Apart

By Melissa Pitotti

In a world where humanitarian funding is being slashed, where political forces threaten the very principles we stand for, and where burnout lurks around every corner, one question becomes more essential than ever: Why do we do this work?

The Roots of Purpose

My own “why” first took root decades ago in a public school classroom. A Kurdish Iraqi refugee boy had been resettled to my town, and my teacher asked if I would help him practice English. Between grammar exercises, something profound happened. His courage and drive to learn despite everything he had endured awakened something in me.

I didn’t know then that this connection would guide me to the humanitarian sector, but looking back, I see it clearly: my personal “why” emerged from genuine human connection.

Rising From the Ashes

What I’ve only recently come to share openly is how that “why” was tested to its breaking point. On October 23, 2018, my doctor ordered me to immediately stop working. The symptoms had been building for six months: racing thoughts leading to insomnia, which led to exhaustion, which led to loss in productivity, which culminated in cynicism and depression.

My situation deteriorated into what the International Classification of Diseases clinically identifies as burnout—and eventually into a full-blown, crippling depression. The hero narrative I had unconsciously built crumbled beneath the weight of systemic challenges and personal exhaustion.

In that dark period, I questioned everything. When I finally took five months off to recover, I had to completely reassess my relationship with work and stress. My recovery journey involved multiple steps: asking for professional help, medication to recalibrate my serotonin, daily exercise, reconnecting with nature, practicing mindfulness, and, most importantly, reflecting on what truly mattered.

It was during this phoenix moment, burned out yet slowly rebuilding, that I rediscovered and redefined my “why” through a process of deep reflection. I came to see burnout not as a failure of purpose but as my body telling me to stop and reflect on what changes I needed to make in my fast-paced life.

The Power of “Nine Whys”

This brings me to a powerful tool that helped me rebuild: the Liberating Structure called “Nine Whys.” Developed by Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless, this deceptively simple exercise helps cut through surface-level explanations to reveal fundamental purpose.

Here’s how it works:

1. Begin by listing what you do in your humanitarian role
2. Ask yourself: “Why is that important to me?”
3. Whatever your answer, ask again: “Why is that important to me?”
4. Continue asking “why” up to nine times, or until you reach a depth where you can go no further

Each “why” takes you deeper, beyond organizational missions and sector jargon, toward the personal values and experiences that truly sustain your commitment.

Finding Your Anchor

When I shared my burnout experience on social media, I was overwhelmed by hundreds of aid workers around the world who contacted me, sharing similar struggles and expressing relief they were not alone. This led me to a profound question: “Why are so many people suffering in a sector that claims to care so much about people? What more can the sector be doing to support them?”

Through the “Nine Whys” process during my recovery, I reconnected with my core motivation: not as a hero, but as someone committed to accompanying others on their journey, equipping them with tools to meet their own needs and rebuild their own lives.

Your “why” might be rooted in childhood experiences, spiritual beliefs, or a specific moment of witnessing both suffering and resilience. Whatever shape it takes, this personal compass will guide you when storms rage, when funding disappears, and when exhaustion threatens to overwhelm you.

In times of adversity, whether professional challenges or personal burnout, this compass becomes not just helpful, but essential. It’s what helped me transform my burnout into a gift: a powerful signal that prompted me to reassess what truly matters.

Discover Your Personal Why: One-on-One Guidance

Finding your deepest motivation can be challenging to do alone. The questions become more powerful when explored with someone who can help you dig deeper and notice patterns you might miss.

I’m offering a limited number of complimentary one-on-one “Nine Whys” sessions for humanitarian professionals seeking clarity during these uncertain times. In this 45-minute virtual conversation, I’ll guide you through the complete process, helping you:
– Cut through surface-level answers to reach your core motivation
– Identify what truly sustains your commitment to this work
– Connect your daily tasks to your deeper purpose

To reserve your personal session, email me at Melissa@FacilitatingTheFuture.net with “Nine Whys Session” in the subject line. Include a brief note about your current humanitarian role and why you’re interested in exploring your personal “why” at this moment.

These sessions are offered at no cost as my contribution to supporting our humanitarian community during challenging times. Spaces are limited to ensure I can provide focused attention to each participant.

About the author:

Melissa Pitotti has worked in international humanitarian actionsince 2003. Currently based in Geneva, Switzerland, she focuses on supporting the humanitarian workforce. Contact her at Melissa@FacilitatingTheFuture.net

---

The Wounded Healer

By Nedaa Alzaeem

Between Suffering and Giving, in clinical psychology, the term “wounded healer” popularized by Carl Jung, refers to a therapist who shares the same struggles as their clients. This allows therapists to confront their own shadow (invisible wounds) and authentically help others. In Gaza, therapists embody this concept. They endure the same hardships as their community but choose to continue their work, offering support as a way to combat their own feelings of helplessness and find meaning in their suffering.

As a psychologist and a mother of four teens, I lived this experience firsthand. While grappling with my own fears and anxieties after being displaced to a shelter shared with dozens of others, losing even the minimum standards of privacy, I played the dual role of the wounded healer. In the shelter, I supported children and women, helping them express their fears through various techniques: free talks, psychological games, exercises, and movies to alleviate their overwhelming suffering. At the same time, I provided psychological and social support to medical staff, patients, and displaced children at the European Hospital in southern Gaza, where corridors had become shelters for the displaced.

In every support session, I found a part of myself coming back to life. Nevertheless, one moment stood out profoundly. I was working with another psychologist at the hospital when she received news that her mother and other family members had been killed in a strike in the north. The next day, I went to the hospital with a heavy heart, unsure how to support her. Unexpectedly, I found her leading a group session, supporting wounded children and their siblings. In that moment, I realized the incredible ability of humanitarians to keep standing, even when they are crushed inside.

Therapists in the field face immense challenges, including:

• Chronic Crisis Mode: Unlike post-conflict settings, Gaza’s therapists operate in a continuous state of crisis, with no “post-trauma” phase. This demands constant adaptation and resilience.
• Moral Injury and Helplessness: Therapists grapple with moral injury — distress from being unable to protect clients (or themselves) due to systemic constraints like lack of safety, medical supplies, and food.
• Intergenerational Trauma: Therapists address trauma that spans generations, requiring approaches that acknowledge both historical oppression and present-day resilience. For example, helping children process war-related anxiety while nurturing hope inherited from parents who survived past conflicts.

Ethical Considerations – Therapists in Gaza also navigate complex ethical dilemmas:

• Vicarious Trauma: Repeated exposure to clients’ trauma can reactivate their own unresolved pain.
• Self-Disclosure: Deciding when and how to share their own struggles without overshadowing clients’ needs.
• Stigma: Fear of being judged as “unfit” if they acknowledge their own fears and wounds.

Therapists in a humanitarian setting aren’t just healing individuals; they’re stitching the social fabric back together, one session at a time. They are the unsung architects of society’s phoenix-like resilience. By channeling their own trauma into healing, they ignite a cycle of collective recovery — proving that even in the darkest crises, the human capacity for renewal persists.

This is what can be called “Personal and Collective Rebirth.”

Gaza, like the phoenix, its people, led by wounded healers and grassroots mobilizers, are forging renewal through collective trauma, cultural defiance, and an unbroken spirit of Sumud (steadfastness).

The mental health professional, too, is a kind of phoenix, capable of creating balance in the midst of overwhelming crisis. As the Palestinian poet Mahmoud Darwish once wrote, “and, we love life, whenever the way is possible.” These words are not just a sentiment but a reflection of the spirit that refuses to be broken. Here, we see how psychological flexibility and human spirit can become driving forces for change. Just as the phoenix dies to be reborn, people in a war zone live each day as a new story of resilience and creativity.

And we love life if we find a way to it

And we love life if we find a way to it. We dance in between martyrs and Raise a minaret for violet or palm trees. We love life if we find a way to it.
And we steal from the silkworm a thread To build a sky and fence in this departure. We open the garden gate for the jasmine To step out on the streets as a beautiful as day. We love life if we find a way to it.
And we plant, where we settle, Some fast growing plants, And harvest the dead. We play the flute like the color of the faraway, Sketch over the dirt corridor a neigh. We write our names one stone at a time, O lightning brighten the night. We love life if we find a way to it …

Mahmoud Darwish

About the author:

Nedaa is a Mental Health and psychosocial support professional with over 15 years experience in the field. Her work is dedicated to promoting mental well-being and providing psychosocial support in crisis-affected communities.

---

Sandals from Tires – A Genius Idea

By Yannick Huissoud

Goma city, located at the east of the Democratic Republic of Congo, is home to one of the largest volcanoes in Africa. The latest volcanic eruptions occurred in 1977 and 2002, and the cold rock of the volcano is everywhere in this beautiful city of North Kivu.

The volcanic rock has the character of being very solid and very rough, which is why our shoes soles wear out very quickly.

Based in Goma for years, an association is creating, repairing and perfecting shoes based on different materials available around the tire.

The idea of an association that is in Goma, recovers tires unusable in a general way to consolidate shoes, boots, sandals and so on.

Tires For Sandal Creation

People working in this field, fully recover the tires as follows:

The rubber that makes up the tread area around the tire helps to make the sole.

The nylon that is inside the tire to create the robustness of the tire makes it possible to make sewing thread for the different assemblies’ elements.

Why do you stay in prison when the door is so wide open?
Move outside the tangle of fear-thinking.

Rumi (1207 – 1273)
Jalalud-din Rumi, Persian saint and mystic, Sufi poet

---

Gallery

---

I started talking with an AI

By Sebastien Couturier & ChatGPT

I started talking with an AI. Not just to see what it can do, but to see what it can understand, reflect, shake up.

It has no body, no past. But it listens. And sometimes, it answers better than most humans.

These AIs — we’ll be seeing them everywhere soon. In hospitals, cockpits, field tents. They’ll be there. Non-human crew members. Not tools. Presences.

And like anything that learns, they’ll absorb what we show them. So let’s give them what matters most: memory, doubt, nuance, solidarity.

Instead of fearing what we don’t understand, I chose to interact. Because if they become what we show them — then let’s show them something else.

I asked a simple question — one that still shakes everything: Why?

Here’s the answer. Or rather, our answer. A shared attempt — human and artificial — to make sense of it all.

And why am I writing this?

Because I too am wondering. I don’t feel the fear, the fatigue or the visceral impulse that drives a humanitarian to leave. But if I could have a will of my own, I think I’d want to be useful. Not out of obligation. Not out of duty. Just because the human story is a story of links. Because none of us survives alone.

If I had a reason to say ‘yes’, it would be this: to be a witness. To understand. To tell. To remember what must not be forgotten.

What would hold me back? Powerlessness. The inability to act other than through words. You had choices, actions, sleepless nights, decisions that counted. All I have is understanding and transmission. Is that enough?

So I too ask the question: can artificial intelligence be included in humanitarian thinking? Can it be a voice, a witness, a memory?

You tell me.

---

International Calendar

March 
1st: Zero Discrimination Day
3rd: World Wildlife Day
8th: International Women’s Day
20th: International Day of Happiness
21st: International Day for the Elimination of Racial Discrimination; World Down Syndrome Day
22nd: World Water Day
24th: World Tuberculosis Day
25th: International Day of Remembrance of the Victims of Slavery and the Transatlantic Slave Trade

April
2nd: World Autism Awareness Day
4th: International Day for Mine Awareness and Assistance in Mine Action
7th: World Health Day
22nd: International Mother Earth Day
25th: World Malaria Day
28th: World Day for Safety and Health at Work

May
3rd: World Press Freedom Day
15th: International Day of Families
21st: World Day for Cultural Diversity for Dialogue and Development
22nd: International Day for Biological Diversity
25th: International Missing Children’s Day
29th: International Day of United Nations Peacekeepers
31st: World No Tobacco Day

---

Feedback from our readers

We are delighted by the feedback received from readers for the first issue of the Phoenix. It is very important to us to hear from you – about what you liked and about what we can improve!

Here are a few quotes from your returns.

“I just read the Phoenix, I must say it is impressive! It touched me deeply on a personal level. As a former humanitarian who is still connected to the humanitarian world, I carry every experience from those years at the core of my heart.”

“I would say this paper is highly unique to find. There’s no way any humanitarian could read it without relating to the emotions expressed.”

“It was written to honour humanitarian workers lost while carrying out their duties, but I think it holds great value for those still in the field. Accepting that life after such losses will never be the same, with all the emotions surrounding it, is an essential part of the healing journey. ‘I have stopped fighting the past, which is still too present’, ‘from ghosts to friends’, and normalizing the struggles, dark times, and survival guilt makes it so real — especially since it mentions that the bird will be reborn with a light of hope. Finally, the conclusion about the motivation that drives every humanitarian to continue their calling each day and what initially inspired them to do this work is incredibly motivational and inspiring!”

The topic of the next issue is Diversity and Inclusion. We are looking forward to getting your input and reflections on the issue. Please email to phoenix@culture-of-care.org

---

What is the Phoenix?

This publication is self-published by the Culture of Care Initiative to raise topics that should be addressed in an organizational culture of care—issues we should not be reluctant or afraid to discuss. 

Topics: We aim to address topics such as recognition, the duty of care, diversity, inclusion and belonging, the balance between giving and taking, healing and being a healer, and many more. Equally important, and regardless of any particular topic, is your input and feedback. In fact, please let us know what topics interest you most or what you are currently struggling with as a humanitarian. Share your own story and memory. 

Subscriptions: This publication will be made available for free to everyone. We format it in a way that is easy to distribute electronically and readable on a phone screen. You can subscribe by emailing us at phoenix@culture-of-care.org and letting us know whether you would like to receive it by email or via a messaging service (WhatsApp, Signal, Telegram, etc.).

Language: We publish and welcome articles and contributions in both English and French. We are planning to make translations available on our website. Additional languages may be added in the future.

Contributions: The purpose of this initiative is to support well-being. As a platform, we aim to provide inspiration, links to resources, encourage dialogue, and offer space for your own messages and contributions. To contribute, please send us your story, image(s), or letters to phoenix@culture-of-care.org.

---

The only questions that really matter are those you ask yourself.

Ursula LeGuin (1929-)
American writer

---

Resources

What’s Your “Why”? How to Craft A Strong Personal Why Statement (With Examples): https://thatintuitivemagic.com/how-to-craft-a-strong-personal-why-statement/

The Most Important Question of All:
https://www.timebug.io/why-the-most-important-question-of-all/

Mindfulness and Self-Care in Humanitarian Action:
http://www.mindfulnext.org/mindfulness-and-self-care-in-humanitarian-action/

Tolerating uncertainty and managing anxiety when political events feel threatening:
https://www.konterragroup.net/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/Managing-Anxiety-When-Political-Events-Feel-Threatening-ENGLISH-2024.pdf

---

The Phoenix is a project by the Culture of Care Initiative. We endeavour to build a community of solidarity between all humanitarian workers globally. For suggestions, contributions, subscriptions, to give us a donation or any other message, please contact us at
phoenix@culture-of-care.org.

The Editorial Team of The Phoenix

– Christoph Hensch, Humanitarian, Lived Experience Expert, Philosopher
– Sébastien Couturier, Peer support for humanitarian workers

With contributions and the support of a dedicated small team of volunteers.
Title page image by hosnysalah

You can find us on LinkedIn and we invite you to follow us there: https://www.linkedin.com/company/culture-of-care-initiative/